Are HDD Still Good For Gaming? | Smart Upgrade Guide

Guide / By

Yes, HDD still work for gaming, but slow loads make SSDs better; use HDD for bulk storage and SSD for your active games.

As prices fell and game sizes grew, the “where do I install this?” question got tricky. The short answer many folks hear is “buy an SSD and forget HDD.” That skips real trade‑offs. If you play a wide mix of titles and keep a big library, a hard drive can still earn a spot in your setup. The right split—SSD for the games you launch a lot, HDD for everything else—keeps costs down without turning every session into a waiting room.

Are HDD Still Good For Gaming Today? Use Cases That Work

Hard drives remain useful in a gaming PC. They shine when capacity matters more than seconds saved on a loading screen. Big open‑worlds benefit most from SSDs, but not every game stretches storage that way. If you’re playing turn‑based, retro, visual novels, 2D indies, or older AAA titles, the gap feels smaller once you’re past the first load.

There’s also the backlog angle. Many players keep hundreds of gigabytes installed just to avoid redownloading. An HDD lets you park those “install‑and‑forget” games while your SSD stays lean for the current rotation. That combo cuts down on shuffling and keeps patch day less painful.

What HDD Do Well For Gamers

Capacity Per Dollar

Terabytes on a budget is where spinning disks still win. You can add 4–8 TB of space for less than a mid‑range NVMe. That headroom fits the huge downloads that modern games ship, plus mods, captures, and local backups.

Archiving And Backlog

Think of a hard drive as your library shelf. Keep the “always installed” titles, co‑op staples you revisit on weekends, or seasonal games you rotate into play. When a sale drops a bundle, you can install the lot without worrying about space on your SSD.

Media, Mods, And Tools

Texture packs, shader caches, ReShade presets, and video exports chew through space. Storing these on an HDD prevents your fast drive from becoming a junk drawer. Keep the game binaries on SSD and the extras on HDD to keep both tidy.

Where HDD Fall Short In Gaming

Load Times And Streaming

Rotational latency and seek time slow random reads. Open‑world engines stream textures and meshes while you move; a slow disk can cause pop‑in or hitching when the world pulls data in chunks. Fast SSDs reduce those stalls and shorten the time between death and respawn.

Patch Days And Copies

Platform launchers rewrite large archives during updates. On an HDD, those write‑heavy steps can drag. If your library lives on a hard drive, keep some free space so writes don’t thrash near the end of the disk.

Competitive Sessions

Chasing load‑in firsts for matches or raids? SSDs speed level transitions and cut boot time for shaders. The gain doesn’t raise your FPS directly, but it trims the dead time before each round.

SSD + HDD Hybrid Setup That Feels Snappy

Most gaming rigs run best with a split. Put Windows, drivers, and fast‑loading games on SSD. Use HDD for the backlog, single‑player epics you pop in and out of, or titles with long campaigns that you won’t launch daily.

What To Install On An SSD

  • Live‑service and competitive titles you boot every day.
  • Open‑world games that stream assets while you move.
  • Engines that precompile lots of shaders at launch.
  • Anything that uses modern IO tech on Windows like DirectStorage.

What To Keep On An HDD

  • Backlog titles you revisit on weekends.
  • Classics, retro packs, emulators, and small indies.
  • Big single‑player games you’ve finished but want handy.
  • Video captures, mods, and exported projects.

Simple Library Management

Steam, Epic, Battle.net, and others let you create multiple library folders across drives. On Steam, you can add another library path and move installed games between SSD and HDD without a full redownload. The steps live in the client’s settings and take only a minute. If you want the official walkthrough, see the Steam move installation guide.

DirectStorage, NVMe, And What It Means For HDD

Windows includes DirectStorage, an API that lets games pull data with less overhead and move decompression work to the GPU. The biggest wins show up on NVMe SSDs, where many small reads happen in parallel with light CPU duty. Hard drives don’t get the same headroom, so asset patterns that make NVMe shine still crawl on mechanical disks. Learn more in Microsoft’s DirectStorage overview.

None of that makes HDD useless. It just nudges your install choices. Put the handful of titles that benefit the most on SSD, then let your hard drive host the rest. That way you get buttery loads where they matter and cheap space everywhere else.

How To Pick A Hard Drive For Gaming Storage

Capacity And RPM

Look for 7200 RPM when you can; it trims seek time and raises throughput compared with many 5400 RPM models. Capacity matters too. Larger drives place data on outer tracks where the platter moves under the head faster, so early fills can read a bit quicker.

CMR Beats SMR For Steady Writes

Shingled models (SMR) pack bits tightly but slow down under sustained writes, which shows up during patches and large installs. Conventional recording (CMR) behaves more predictably when a launcher rewrites big archives. If the spec sheet doesn’t say, check model‑specific resources before you buy.

Cache Size And SATA Link

Drives with larger DRAM cache handle bursts better. Pair that with a clean SATA connection on its own cable when possible. Avoid filling the last few percent of the disk; fragmented free space makes long installs sluggish.

Expected Differences: HDD Vs. SATA SSD Vs. NVMe

Here’s what most players feel in day‑to‑day use. A typical hard drive moves big files at a couple hundred megabytes per second with slower small reads. A SATA SSD lands around the 500 MB/s range with quick access to tiny files. NVMe pushes well past that and handles many requests in parallel. In practice that means shorter boot screens, faster fast‑travel, and fewer stalls when an engine streams data.

Frame rate hinges on CPU and GPU, so storage speed shows up around the edges. You won’t turn a 60 FPS title into 100 FPS with an SSD, but you will get back minutes of time over a week of play.

What If You Only Have An HDD Right Now?

You can still have a smooth time with smart setup. Trim startup apps so Windows boots faster, leave free space, and place your pagefile on the same disk as Windows. Close launchers you don’t need during play so the disk isn’t juggling background reads.

Power And Sleep Settings

Open Windows power settings and switch the plan to “High performance” or the gaming plan your laptop vendor ships. Set “Turn off hard disk after” to “Never” while you play so the drive doesn’t spin down mid‑session.

Health Check

Run a quick SMART check in your drive maker’s tool. If the reallocated sector count rises or you hear repeat clicks, back up first. A drive that’s aging can feel uneven long before it fails.

External Enclosures And Laptops

Playing on a laptop with a small SSD? An external 2.5‑inch HDD in a USB 3.0 enclosure works well for storage. Keep your daily games on the internal SSD and move your backlog to the external drive. For better load times on the road, a small external SSD gives near‑SATA speeds over USB‑C.

Upgrade Paths That Make Sense

If your motherboard has an open M.2 slot, add an NVMe for your boot drive and keep the hard drive for bulk installs. On older boards without M.2, a SATA SSD brings a big feel‑good jump. You can still keep the HDD installed for capacity, then migrate libraries at your pace.

Troubleshooting Slow HDD Performance

Check The Cable And Port

Use a 6 Gb/s SATA port and a fresh cable. A loose connector or an old 3 Gb/s port can bottleneck reads and writes. Move the cable to a known good port on the chipset when in doubt.

Controller Mode

AHCI mode in BIOS enables native features and helps NCQ behave well under load. If Windows was installed in IDE mode, changing it without prep can break boot. Search your board model for the safe switch steps before you flip that setting.

Background Tasks

Indexing, cloud drive sync, and malware scans hammer disks with small reads. Pause or schedule them outside of play time. Game launchers with auto‑update also press the disk; turn off auto start for the ones you don’t need every day.

Quick Drive ID

Want to check which disk is HDD or SSD from a prompt? This PowerShell command lists the type:

Get-PhysicalDisk | Format-Table FriendlyName, MediaType, Size

Measure Your Disk

Curious about your own speeds? Run a quick benchmark that ships with Windows:

winsat disk -drive C

Swap C for the letter of the drive you want to test. You’ll see sequential and random numbers that give a rough idea of where your disk sits.

Copy Large Folders Faster

When you move a big library between drives, use robocopy so you can resume if the transfer pauses:

robocopy "D:\Games" "E:\Games" /E /COPY:DAT /R:1 /W:1 /MT:16 /NFL /NDL /NP

This copies all files and subfolders, keeps timestamps, retries once on errors, and uses multiple threads to lift throughput on fast links.

Common Scenarios And The Best Drive To Use

Use this quick map to decide where a game or asset fits. Place new installs on SSD when fast loads change the feel of the game. Park everything else on HDD to stretch your budget.

Scenario Install On Why
Competitive Shooter Or BR SSD (NVMe or SATA) Faster map loads and snappier transitions between matches.
Open‑World RPG With Heavy Streaming SSD (NVMe preferred) Reduces pop‑in and hitching during traversal across big zones.
Turn‑Based Or Visual Novel HDD Load times matter less once inside a scene; saves space on SSD.
Large Backlog And Finished Titles HDD Cheap capacity for installs you don’t launch daily.
Mods, Captures, Exports HDD Keeps SSD clear for active games and the OS.
Creator Suites And Dev Tools SSD Faster compile and asset indexing when you build or edit.

Answering The Real Question: Should You Still Buy An HDD For Gaming?

Yes—if you want cheap space alongside a fast primary drive. The smart path for a new build is an NVMe SSD as the boot and “now playing” drive, plus a roomy HDD for everything else. If your budget only fits one device today, start with an SSD sized for your main titles and add a hard drive when sales pop up. If you need the vendor steps for moving games later, the Steam move installation guide walks through it in the client.

HDD are still good for gaming when used as a partner to SSD, not a replacement. Make the SSD handle the games where fast IO changes the feel of play, and let the HDD stretch your library. That mix delivers smooth sessions without draining your wallet.